Italy accuses EU allies of failing to strengthen Red Sea shipping security

Rome: Italy’s Defence Minister Guido Crosetto has criticised European Union member states for failing to take concrete measures to strengthen maritime security in the Red Sea, warning that the bloc’s naval mission remains inadequately supported despite growing threats to international shipping.

Crosetto said European governments had yet to respond meaningfully to his calls for additional naval deployments and resources to reinforce Operation Aspides, the EU’s maritime security mission launched in 2024 to protect commercial vessels from attacks by Yemen’s Iran-aligned Houthi movement.

Speaking in Rome on November 10, the Italian defence minister expressed disappointment over the lack of tangible progress, despite raising the issue with European partners and securing an understanding from EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas.

“I have yet to see anything concrete,” Crosetto said, while acknowledging that Kallas had fully understood the importance of Italy’s concerns and the need to strengthen the mission.

In September, Crosetto urged the European Union to reinforce Aspides as attacks on commercial shipping and growing instability across the Middle East heightened concerns about the security of vital international maritime corridors.

Following the Italian minister’s appeal, Kallas wrote to the bloc’s 27 member states, urging them to increase their contributions to the naval operation. She indicated that more than 10 warships would be required to make the mission sufficiently effective.

However, discussions among EU governments have so far failed to produce a concrete agreement on additional deployments. Differences over military resources and the reluctance of some member states to commit naval assets have reportedly complicated efforts to expand the operation.

Crosetto also questioned the unequal distribution of responsibilities among European countries, arguing that Italy was shouldering a disproportionately large share of the burden despite having fewer resources than several of its European partners.

“About one third of European operations depend on Italy’s contribution. Other countries, far larger than us, contribute much, much less,” he said.

Emphasising the need for greater collective responsibility, Crosetto argued that European countries should contribute fairly if they considered maritime security operations strategically important.

The minister’s remarks highlight growing divisions within the European Union over military burden-sharing at a time when instability in the Middle East is threatening major commercial shipping routes and international energy supplies.

The security situation has become increasingly complicated amid the US-Israel war on Iran, which has disrupted maritime traffic through strategically important waterways, including the Bab el-Mandeb Strait and the Strait of Hormuz. The disruption has raised concerns about shipping costs, energy security and additional inflationary pressures on the global economy.

The Red Sea and the adjoining Suez Canal remain particularly important for international commerce, providing a vital connection between European and Asian markets. Any prolonged disruption to shipping through the region can force vessels to take longer alternative routes, increasing transportation costs and delaying deliveries.

The economic implications are especially significant for Italy. According to Assarmatori, one of the country’s principal shipowners’ associations, approximately 40 per cent of Italy’s international trade passes through the Suez Canal at the northern end of the Red Sea.

The Houthi movement has intensified attacks on commercial shipping and strategic infrastructure, further complicating efforts to restore confidence among international shipping operators. Saudi Arabia has also carried out strikes against Houthi targets in Yemen, adding another dimension to the already volatile regional security environment.

Operation Aspides was established to provide defensive maritime protection, including escorting commercial vessels and strengthening surveillance in response to threats against international shipping. Its effectiveness, however, depends heavily on the availability of naval vessels and adequate operational resources from participating countries.

Crosetto’s intervention has therefore renewed the debate over whether the European Union can sustain an effective collective maritime security presence without a more equitable commitment from its member states.

With major trade and energy routes facing mounting security challenges, Italy is pressing its European partners to move beyond diplomatic assurances and translate their commitments into practical military contributions.

The dispute also exposes a broader challenge for European security policy: ensuring that collective responsibilities are matched by collective action at a time when instability in one of the world’s most strategically important maritime regions carries consequences far beyond the Middle East.